A Dorset Landowner faces a £3million bill to remove 28,500 tonnes of illegally dumped rubbish from a former quarry owned by his family business.
Paul Wilkes blames the Environment Agency squarely for failing to act.
Mr Wilkes had leased the disused site to waste operator Hillier Recycling, expecting it to deposit only inert materials such as soil and rubble.
Within a year, however, he discovered the company was treating the quarry as a dumping ground for household refuse it had no plans to process.
Over seven years, the firm amassed towering 50ft mounds containing plastics, electrical items and hazardous petroleum hydrocarbons, substances that can be carcinogenic.
After raising the alarm with the EA, the very body that had granted Hillier Recycling its waste permits, Mr Wilkes was assured the situation was under control.
Yet it took the agency six years to revoke those permits.
During that period, lorries continued arriving constantly to deposit waste.
Mr Wilkes told the BBC: “We actually said to the Environment Agency can you please stop them coming and tipping and they said ‘don’t worry we’ve got it all in hand’, and nothing happened. The lorries still came.”
In desperation, his employees physically blocked the quarry entrance with a lorry.
The EA’s response was to instruct them to remove the vehicle, citing a breach of lease conditions.
Agency records show officials visited the site more than 20 times between 2015 and 2022, asking Hillier to address permit violations.
Despite this, the company was permitted to continue handling waste until September 2022, when it finally abandoned the quarry.
Rebecca Bomers, an environmental consultant from Somerton Environmental, brought in to assess the waste, argued the permits should never have been approved.
The site lacked an impermeable surface to prevent contamination leaching into the ground, and no building existed to house and treat commercial waste indoors, creating a significant fire hazard.
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS
Tap water will be turned off on a rota for one million Britons if severe drought conditions worsenBritish woman was manipulated for years and murdered by predator on fetish site, court hearsLib Dem councillor blames Reform’s ‘vile propaganda’ for swastika graffiti
She noted that in May 2018, the EA identified highly combustible materials stored in the open but gave Hillier only two months to produce an action plan.
More remarkably, the agency classified the site as “overall compliant” in April 2019 despite the required building never having been constructed.
Ms Bomers said: “It should never have been green lit. There’s a compliance form that says it’s fit for purpose. To lie that blatantly can’t be put down to a mistake or even incompetence.”
She added that the EA had even warned the Wilkes family against revoking Hillier’s licence, claiming it could obstruct their investigation.
Ms Bomers said: “The poor landowners are left to pick up the pieces of the regulator’s incompetence. It’s so unfair and so biased.”
Anna Willetts, the environmental lawyer representing the family, described the case as “astounding and absolutely outrageous.”
She said: “They have the power to step in and clear this but they are not because they think my client can pay.”
Hillier Recycling entered liquidation in 2024, after which the EA ordered Mr Wilkes to clear the site or face prosecution.
He is now appealing that order in court.
Three men pleaded guilty in September to offences connected to the site and are due to be sentenced at Bournemouth Court next week.
The EA said it could not comment on active legal proceedings.
Our Standards:
The GB News Editorial Charter

